PortfolioMenu

The Comparative Degree: ADDIE VS SAM

Share in

So, here’s the thing about Instructional System Design models (ISDs), they have been around for a long time; studied, analyzed, rigorously followed all across the globe. ISDs are processes that ensure that learning does not become haphazard, and is created following certain steps that provide measurable outcomes. In other words, ISDs are structural frameworks and Instructional designers are responsible to creating learning experience which ensures that learners achieve the learning outcomes by following any particular model.

In this series of blogs, called ‘Comparative Degree’ we plan on analyzing the key differences among famous instructional models theories etc. In the very first one we are going to talk about ADDIE and SAM, both models abbreviations of the process itself.

ADDIE stands for Analyze, Design, Development, Implement, Evaluate and SAM is the abbreviation for Successive Approximation Model. The similarity is that both models are based on iterative process. And, the differences? Here we go.

1st Differentiator - History

ADDIE has a long-standing history. The fact that this model was developed by the United States military after World War II, makes it seem almost like a veteran. SAM is a new model created by Allen Interactions, and has become a popular alternative to ADDIE in a relatively short time.

2nd Differentiator - Process

Simply put ADDIE is a linear process, while SAM is more of a cyclical process. Though both models emphasize on the importance and inevitability of iterations, it is applied differently in both.

In ADDIE one step is the starting point for the next, though iterations are made based on the results of formative analysis for each phase. So, basically you analyze the needs and define the constrains, then design learning activities, assessments, choose the media elements etc. Based on the design begins the arduous process of development, evaluation is done at this stage and changes made as and where required. This is followed by implementation and final evaluation. The strength of this model is that it depends on perfection in each stage, which however is also considered to be its greatest flaw.

SAM model is based on faster outcomes, and making changes as a part of the process. According to its creators, “it begins with performance so that the clients end with performance.” It actually begins with a quick preparation phase—where information and the necessary all the background knowledge is gathered. Then comes the Iterative design phase, which begins with Savvy Start- an initial collaborative brainstorming meeting which leads onto the iterative process of design, prototype, and review. Following this comes the Iterative Development Phase that includes development, implementation and evaluation. The changes are made as quickly as possible in order to minimize future risks.

3rd Differentiator - Time & Money

Though there are no actual evidence to prove that one process is costlier than the other, it sure has its difference as far as time is concerned. And if you believe that time is money, then cost would be affected too (indirectly). SAM is considered to be a relatively faster than ADDIE, and is more deadline-driven. However, being a fast process the chances of error are on the higher side too.

4th Differentiator - School of Thought

Some do speculate that ADDIE is a process from a different era, and that too much emphasis on process and perfection, strict order of content presentation etc. makes it inflexible towards change and creativity. SAM in the other hand is said to focus on learner experiences, engagement, and motivation.

In our opinion, both models are unique in their own way. The trick is to use them appropriately and in accordance with the project and client requirements.

We will be back with another ‘Comparative Degree’ post soon. Until then Keep Reading!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe With Us

Knowzies Voice
Let’s connect and spread knowledge together
Recent Posts
July 2, 2020
Why Microlearning And Mobile Learning Is an Essential Combination in Today’s Age For L&D

In a modern world driven by app-based technologies and workplace applications, mobile is an essential device. A Deloitte report states that “consumers today check their

Read More
June 25, 2020
Importance of eLearning in Remote On-boarding of Employees

eLearning is important for remote onboarding. Instead of going the traditional way of listing out the importance, what if we use a scenario instead?

Read More
June 17, 2020
Re-Evaluating Your eLearning Development Strategy in Wake of Pandemic - Key Tips

Almost half a year has gone by and individuals, organizations, families, institutes, and mankind as a whole has been finding ways to adapt to a situation that had never been foreseen.

Read More
June 3, 2020
Converting Heavy Text into e-Learning - Key Tips

In interesting research published under the title, “Don’t throw away your printed books: A meta-analysis on the effects of reading media on reading comprehension”, researchers from Spain and Israel discussed the screen inferiority effect

Read More
May 21, 2020
Key Tips for Rapid eLearning Video Development

Start. Action. Cut. Is that how you perceive video development? Well, can’t say that’s wrong as far as the popular concept of directing videos goes.

Read More
Recent Case Studies
December 19, 2020
Only Assessment Skill Assessment App

Knowzies Team developed a solution that consisted of a responsive web application with admin and user functionality. The admin can create assessments and assign those to users based on time and date. There are 6 different types of questions that can be created or bulk uploaded by the admin. This is a highly scalable architecture and is built to handle the load of as much as more than 5000 concurrent users. It had 4 types of users viz super admin, evaluator, and user.

Read More
December 17, 2020
On the cloud.io: SAAS Software Review Platform

Knowzies team offered a solution that consisted of a responsive web application that is available in 4 different languages- English, Spanish, Italian, and French. The main portal offered an excellent search facility to search the required product based on category, feature, pricing, country, etc. It also showed the latest trends in the industry and top 3 products based on the user’s reviews. It had 5 different types of modules like Main Page, Categories (further split into subcategories), market analysis and trends, and some useful resources.

Read More
December 14, 2020
Compliance Training App

Knowzies team created a solution that consisted of a responsive web application with multi-portal functionality. The main portal was integrated with the client’s website. An iOS, as well as an Android mobile app, is also part of the solution. It had 4 types of users viz super admin, master admin, sub-admin, and learner. Knowzies team adopted SCRUM methodology for managing this solution which was built across 8 sprints.

Read More
Knowzies is one of the leading eLearning development companies in the US. Let’s trigger a mind-blowing digital transformation in your organization!
© 2021
 All Rights Reserved
Privacy PolicySitemap
envelopecrossarrow-up linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram